Skip to main content

SC Jury Cases · 10 court records · 2004–2026

The rules exist. The warnings recur. Who gets meaningful review?

South Carolina’s own records repeatedly raise questions about protecting jurors and examining interference. Safeguards mean little if the people who need them cannot obtain meaningful review.

A documented collection

Different disputes. Recurring accountability questions.

This collection brings together jury-integrity disputes, official-contact findings, and hearing decisions. It is not an exhaustive census or proof that every allegation was sustained. Convictions upheld, hearings ordered, attorney discipline and a new-trial ruling appear side by side. Each entry describes the outcome as of its opinion date, not a later custody, license or retrial result.

The recurring failures and warnings demand accountability: who contacts jurors, who supplies outside legal guidance, which institutional relationships go undisclosed, whether witnesses are questioned, and how late-discovered evidence is treated. Chris’s family asks why his reported jury-room instruction has not received the full examination it demands.

Official contact, juror nondisclosure and internal deliberations are different categories, not one automatic legal test. Rowell’s substituted September 2024 opinion replaced the older intent-based nondisclosure framework with a prejudice inquiry. State hearing decisions in McCoy and Rowell do not automatically excuse federal successive-petition requirements.

Editorial collection date: November 9, 2026. This is not a new court development.

A fair trial is the State’s duty, not a privilege bought through influence. The family demands immediate examination and prompt lawful rectification of Chris’s conviction. Read the constitutional duty and the family’s demand.

Explore the court records

Jury issue

10 of 10 records · All · Newest first

Central comparison · Colleton County

State v. Murdaugh

· Opinion No. 28329

New trial ordered

Official contact · Hearing access

The Supreme Court found that Clerk of Court Rebecca Hill improperly influenced jurors. A January 2024 hearing had examined the contacts before the case reached the Supreme Court.

The court’s response

The court unanimously reversed the denial of a new trial and remanded. It applied a presumption of prejudice and held the State failed to rebut it.

Why it matters to Woody

The central comparison: South Carolina enforced protection against outside jury influence here. Chris’s family demands full examination of his jury-room evidence under the same constitutional principles.

Scope: A new murder trial, not exoneration. The legal route differs from Woody’s original-jurisdiction petition and federal gatekeeping.

Greenwood County

State v. Rowell

· Opinion No. 28215 · substituted September 18, 2024

Hearing ordered

Juror nondisclosure · Hearing access

A juror had not disclosed a recent arrest. The trial court denied a requested hearing to examine him, even though the State consented to that hearing.

The court’s response

The Supreme Court vacated and remanded for an evidentiary hearing. It required strong reasons for denying inquiry into juror nondisclosure and replaced the older intent-based framework with a prejudice inquiry.

Why it matters to Woody

Relevant to the need to develop jury facts rather than resolve them by assumption. Nondisclosure and outside jury influence remain different legal categories.

Scope: Use this substituted September opinion. The July 17 version was withdrawn; no automatic new trial was ordered.

Thirteenth Judicial Circuit

In the Matter of Jeffrey Alton Phillips

· Opinion No. 28231

Attorney disciplined

Official contact · Juror nondisclosure

An assistant solicitor exchanged texts with a friend serving on a jury in a case prosecuted by colleagues. He asked about the case, discouraged sympathy for the defendant, and urged secrecy.

The court’s response

After the contact was reported, the juror was removed. The Supreme Court accepted admitted misconduct and imposed a six-month suspension retroactive to July 26, 2022.

Why it matters to Woody

A documented example of improper insider contact and a request to conceal it. It supports scrutiny of institutional access without establishing who entered Chris’s jury room.

Scope: Discipline was imposed in 2024 for July 2022 communications. This is not a new-trial ruling or current license-status report.

Laurens County

State v. Green

· Opinion No. 28001 · 432 S.C. 97

Conviction upheld

Official contact

A bailiff answered a juror’s question about what might happen if the jury could not agree. The trial judge questioned each juror and the bailiff.

The court’s response

The Supreme Court affirmed as modified. It found the procedural comment did not rise to constitutional error, while calling for bailiff training and directing substantive jury questions to the judge.

Why it matters to Woody

Directly relevant to the bailiff’s role. The family’s argument distinguishes a procedural remark from the verdict-directed instruction reported in Chris’s evidence.

Scope: The Supreme Court did not hold that every improper bailiff comment triggers presumed prejudice.

Beaufort County

State v. Tucker

· Opinion No. 5552 · 423 S.C. 403

Conviction upheld

Juror nondisclosure · Hearing access

Affidavits and social-media material alleged a juror had not disclosed relationships with people connected to the case. A juror affidavit disputed the allegations. A fuller evidentiary hearing was refused.

The court’s response

The Court of Appeals affirmed, finding support for the trial judge’s rejection of the alleged concealment and refusal to conduct further inquiry.

Why it matters to Woody

Illustrates disputes about what evidence is enough to require live examination. It does not establish that the alleged relationships or bias were proven.

Scope: Historical outcome; its intentional-versus-unintentional concealment framework predates Rowell.

Ninth Judicial Circuit

In the Matter of Michael O’Brien Nelson

· Opinion No. 27327 · 406 S.C. 201

Attorney disciplined

Official contact · Juror nondisclosure

An assistant solicitor had improper contacts with his cousin while the cousin served on a jury. The relationship was not disclosed during jury selection, and phone records documented repeated contacts.

The court’s response

The Supreme Court accepted an agreement admitting misconduct and imposed a six-month suspension, retroactive to June 1, 2013. The juror had been excused during trial.

Why it matters to Woody

An official disciplinary record of improper prosecutor-juror contact, relevant to accountability for people with institutional access.

Scope: A disciplinary ruling, not a new-trial decision or a statement of current license status.

Spartanburg County

McCoy v. State

· Opinion No. 27214 · 401 S.C. 363

Hearing ordered

Juror nondisclosure · Hearing access

A second PCR application alleged that a juror failed to disclose a family connection to the solicitor. The applicant discovered the connection years later in another trial’s record.

The court’s response

The Supreme Court reversed summary dismissal and remanded for a hearing on disputed timeliness and successiveness questions, with merits review if the procedural requirements were met.

Why it matters to Woody

Closely relevant to late-discovered jury evidence and disputed access to a hearing. It concerns state PCR, not an automatic exception to federal successive-petition rules.

Scope: The historical juror-concealment framework discussed here was later changed by Rowell in 2024.

Fairfield County

State v. Elgin

· Opinion No. 4974

Conviction upheld

Outside information

An investigator’s affidavit reported a juror discussing the trial with her mother and relying on information from outside court. The juror testified at a post-trial hearing.

The court’s response

The Court of Appeals affirmed the denial of a new trial. The court found the misconduct did not prejudice Elgin, noting that the mother’s account favored him.

Why it matters to Woody

An investigator’s account led to direct questioning of a juror. The family wants comparable factual examination of Chris’s reported outside contact.

Scope: Misconduct was examined; the court did not find grounds for a new trial.

Charleston County

State v. Pittman

· Opinion No. 26339 · 373 S.C. 527

Conviction upheld

Outside information

The defense challenged a juror’s conversations with his wife and a bartender, alongside jurors’ later accounts of pressure and misunderstanding about voting. The trial court held a hearing.

The court’s response

The Supreme Court affirmed. It rejected relief on the outside-contact claim and treated the reported pressure and misunderstanding as internal deliberations.

Why it matters to Woody

The source and setting of the influence matter. Chris’s alleged outside instruction must be distinguished from ordinary internal jury discussion.

Scope: The opinion addressed several issues; this entry covers only its jury issues.

Oconee County

State v. Galbreath

· Opinion No. 3812 · 359 S.C. 398

Conviction upheld

Outside information · Hearing access

Post-trial affidavits raised an overheard threat, undisclosed relationships, and incorrect sentencing information shared by a juror. The judge considered affidavits and arguments but did not reconvene the jury.

The court’s response

The Court of Appeals affirmed. It found insufficient prejudice from the outside statement and treated the sentencing discussion as internal jury conduct.

Why it matters to Woody

Shows why identifying an outside source matters. Chris’s central claim concerns a man entering from outside the jury, rather than only jurors misunderstanding one another.

Scope: Historical outcome; apply current law when assessing a new claim.

Equal enforcement

Make the evidence count.

Read the primary sources. Help qualified counsel and investigators examine Chris’s record, preserve evidence and assess lawful remaining remedies. The family asks for an independent examination of the jury evidence and equal enforcement of the Constitution.